Best 10mm Pistols & Handguns: Carry some POWER! It was built to fire a lightweight, high speed small caliber round allowing more rounds per magazine. Add to Cart. The longer barrel made the XM4 more effective and gave it a smaller muzzle blast. They become even more similar which makes the comparison that much more essential. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. 6 years ago. The AR-15 was a direct evolution of the AR-10, which was developed by Eugene Stoner in the 50’s. The first similarity is that both the M4 rifle and AR 15 are American rifles. Sort By. Makes one question … Chuck basically concurred with Rocky in this assessment. In this case, these gaping wounds were created by bullet fragmentation. It also allowed the option of mounting a bayonet and a grenade launcher to the weapon. 3 years ago. Early efforts were disappointing. eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'huntingheart_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_7',138,'0','0'])); There is a lot of talk about the AR-15 and especially M4 both in the news and the firearms community but do you ever wonder what the differences are between them? Vortex Optics Strike Eagle 1-8×24 Riflescope with AR-BDC2 Reticle (30mm Tube) for Very Fast Shooting up Close, and out to Distance! Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates. AR15 / M4 / M16; View as Grid List. Get our PDF with 13 pistol & rifle targets (worth $48) including expert instructions for FREE! One is a bump-fire stock that allows you to simulate full-auto fire. The rifle recoils into the stock when you take a shot. The leading cause that leads to the development of the M4 feed ramp is the gas pressure from the carbine gas system that is increasing along with a high cyclic rate. The M14 was quickly compared to the AK-47 as they faced each other in the Vietnam War. There is a lot of confusion as to exactly what differentiates them. The civilian AR-15 receiver has no accommodation for an auto sear, and that is why it is only capable of semi-auto fire. On an AR 10 the muzzle velocity is around 2700 fps. Learn More. It also needed to maintain a muzzle velocity above the speed of sound and beat the stopping power of the .30 Carbine. The internals of the upper and lower receivers are very similar in both weapons. Velocity and effective firing range also highlight the differences between both rifles. As you can tell, there are very few differences between the two weapons. The reload for the AR-15 is pretty damn quick compared to its peers, while the M4 is a touch slower than the average assault rifle reloads for both the full and tactical reloads. Therefore the conditions that make a bump stock illegal are quite sketchy. The weapon was highly popular during a tour in the East, and Colt closed a deal with Malaya later that year. It’s a unique weapon and all modern M16/M4 variants can be turned into a 5.56/40mm combo so, in essence, it’s in a category all its own. It is smaller, lighter, and just as effective. Logically, The M4 took long strides as compared to AR 15. Stopping power; The AR 10’s heavier 7.62mm and .308 rounds give it more instant stopping power than the AR 15. You have probably identified the M4 rifle with the U.S military troops, while the AR-15 is commonly owned by millions of civilians within the U.S. Brief History. The above two … The weapon is used by the US Armed Forces and has recently been replacing the AR15 as the primary infantry weapon. One more point about the M4 barrel is that it is shaped into an hourglass. Rocky was surprised that both carbines shot as accurately as they did. In the late 80s, after having gone through numerous wars, the American military realized that the area for fighting was increasingly narrowed. The only other AR .22 I’d ever seen or handled was an S&W M&P 15 22. When compared to an AR9 which we discussed above, the AR15 has some differences: -Barrel (chambered in .223/5.56) In technical terms, a carbine is the term for a more compact (shorter barrel) version of an existing rifle. The M4 rifle is a lighter and shorter version of the AR15. Posted by. Before adoption, the weapon was modified by moving the charging handle from under the carrying handle to the back of the lower receiver. The resulting round was the 7.62x51mm round and the M14 rifle. While there is normally a heated debate when comparing these types of weapons, this one is pretty obvious. THE BEST GUN DEALS AND HANDPICKED GEAR RECOMMENDATIONS, Subscribe to our Newsletter and we send you the best deals right into your inbox. The difference between the AR 15 and M4 is that the M4 has either a full-auto or burst fire mode whereas the AR-15 does not. They started producing the AR15 and selling to military services all over the world. I have spent thousands of hours hunting hogs and training hunting dogs, but I’m always learning new stuff and really happy to be sharing them with you! It is smaller, lighter, and just as effective. As for the externals, rail systems and hand guards come with some similar points. The M4 is a bit shorter than the AR15. What’s the Difference Between an SBR AR15 and an AR 15? 36 years old, been hunting and fishing my entire life – love the outdoors, family, and all kinds of hunting and fishing! It has direct impingement and is magazine fed. BONUS OFFER: Get your 500 Page Ammo Comparison Handbook (worth $43) for FREE right into your inbox. Special Forces officers could not get enough, and started pushing for a full scale switch to the AR15. Both the AR-15 and the M4 are based on the Armalite Rifle design from Eugene. Particularly, with 5.66 mm ammunition, Armalite AR 15 features an effective range of 500 yards and has the velocity of up to 3,300 ft. /s. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. It is a 5.56x45mm, air cooled, gas operated weapon. It was thought that the barrel length was ruining the ballistics and degrading the accuracy and range of the weapon. 1. The name derives from the company that first manufactured it. It was said that the M14 was very hard to control when being fired in fully automatic mode. The M16 is based on the prototype of AR 15. There are aftermarket parts filtered into the firearm community and technically lawful for sale, but unlawful when installed. Following this event, the evolution of the AR 15 model was realized and it significantly improved. In addition, it did not carry enough rounds to take on the superior AK-47. It was given an improved rear sight and a cartridge deflector as well. Best 9mm Ammo 2019 [Self-Defense & Target], 6.5 Creedmoor vs .243 Win – Cartridge Comparison, [Review] Taurus 692: One Versatile Revolver. He was promoted to US Air force Chief of Staff shortly after and placed an order for 80,000 of the weapons. That means an AR15 can put more rounds into a target faster. Then in 1961 the Advanced Research Projects Agency sent ten AR15s to South Vietnam. He thought the AR-15 was simpler to operate, but that the Mini-14 would be more durable and reliable in the long run, due to its all steel barreled action and gas piston operation. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'huntingheart_com-leader-2','ezslot_10',151,'0','0']));Barrel length makes AR 15 and M4 different from each other. Development of the M16 required several iterations because of bullet design, firing modes, and structural reliability.The M4 came … Vance felt that the testing methods were biased and had the Army Inspector General confirm his theory. The easiest and most accessible way is to buy a mil-spec lower and M4 handguards, which are both easy to find, and upgrade your AR-15with them. M4, or M4 carbine, can be regarded as a considerable improvement over M16, which is created based on the prototype of Ar15.Logically, we can say that M4 took long strides compared to Ar15. huntingheart.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon. Based on James' personal experience owning both guns in addition to a 2018 weapons trial report by the New Zealand Ministry of Defense, James tells you how the M4 is better than the AUG. Those in charge insisted on a single high-power .30 caliber round that could be used in the new automatic rifle as well as by the new machine gun they were designing. The same is true. Both are available in both automatic and semi-automatic versions. Archived. share. The wound cavity created by the AR15 rounds was impressive, but was thought to be due to the tumbling motion of the bullet caused by the subtle rifling of the barrel. Both the interiors and externals show remarkable resemblance. It’s all metal. The Model 605A CAR-15 Carbine was a shortened version for situations where longer weapons could be unwieldy, such as aboard vehicles or helicopters.It was an improved version of the AR-15 SBR, which was a shorter barrel version of the Colt Armalite AR-15. Carbine vs. Rifle: What’s the Difference? AR-15 VS M4: A Comparison What’s the Difference Between an AR-15 and an M4 rifle? In this episode of TFBTV, James Reeves goes over seven reasons that the AR-15/M-16/M4 carbine is better than the Steyr AUG bullpup. As always, I also tested the ADS times (without and with angled grip) and these are the same for both guns and their hip fire spreads are also the same for standing, kneeling, prone and jogging. It uses 62 grain M855 cartridges. With regards to the internal parts, charging handle, receiver internals, trigger assembly, bolt carrier group, and are similar in both weapons. At most times, it was only around 200 square meters. I noticed that there are two offered, the M4E1 and the standard AR-15 version. The M60 machine gun was also taken on for military use. Both the AR 15 and M4 rifles came into existence in their unique way. This is the development process that has lead to the debate between the M4 VS AR15. The US military needed a hybrid between these two weapons. The following year they received their order, and the year after they received an additional 57,240 rifles. Despite these issues, it was considered an ideal close- quarters weapon as a submachine gun. In the firearm community, it is regarded as a considerable improvement over the M16. In terms of similarities, the two are almost identical. Some parts can turn a semi-automatic firearm into a full automatic firearm mechanically. CMMG Bravo AR-15 Conversion Kit. The rifle was firing these rounds at a speed that caused them to break apart when contacting human flesh. You must pull the trigger a second time to fire another shot. In the past military-style weapons were identical to keep production costs low. The AR15 has gone on to be modified into several other similar weapons. The emergence of the Russian AK-47 forced a redesign of the M14 to increase firepower and dependability, resulting in the adoption of the M16 during the Vietnam War. It has also been swapped out for most submachine guns and handguns in US military service. Unless you join the military or are already serving (and if the latter, then thank you! During World War II, the US military was using the M1 Garand, the M3 “grease gun”, the Thompson submachine gun, the M1 and M2 Carbines, and the M1918 Browning Automatic Rifle. The most notable difference is acquiring permission for using these weapons. It should not be a surprise these two guns are quite similar to each other. In 1994 the US military brought on the XM4 to replace the AR15 in specific roles. The .223/5.56 AR-15 rifle was a direct evolution of the 7.62×51 AR-10, which was developed by Eugene Stoner in the 1950’s. To understand the different types of AR platform rifles, you first need to start with a little history. On the other hand, separate manufactures different from the Colt, called Bushmaster, produced variants of the AR 15 as civil guns to the civilians. Wondering what caliber the AR15 uses, checkout our article on What is the Caliber for AR15 Rifles? In addition, the Secret Service and other federal law enforcement have since adopted the AR15. Or, perhaps, “what’s the difference between a rifle and a carbine.” I’ve got about 30 seconds before you click off this page, so here’s the bottom line up front in the rifle vs. carbine debate. M4E1 vs. Aero AR-15 Upper. M4 is a variant of AR15. This happened after ArmaLite was faced with some financial issues. The M4 rifle is a lighter and shorter version of the AR15. The AR-15 is the name of a design of rifle based upon the original design by Eugene Stoner. It is only a fundamental similarity and has nothing to do with function and use. After the AR15 was adopted by the US military, carbine options were brought on for special operations. If you have an AR-15, rest assured that it is extremely similar to the military M4. In the past military-style weapons were identical to keep production costs low. ), My Husband Hunts and I Hate It: How to Make Your Spouse Love Your Hunting Hobby, Real Avid Bore Boss Clean Storing, Pull Through, Bore Cleaning System, Ultimate Rifle Build Distressed Flag Gun Cleaning Mat 11"x17", Hoppe's No. The concept started in the late 80s, after revelations from numerous wars, the American military realized that the area for fighting was increasingly getting narrowed. With the significant advancements in function and design, the new version of AR 15 gained immense popularity. Very thankful for your business. However, the world considers them such powerful weapons. In general, all you need to understand is that the M4 feed ramps include the barrel extension and upper receiver. With so many variations available now from the Pistol to SBR , or a service rifle to SPR or hunting variety, the AR-15 has developed into a platform suitable for the every man, and all of their needs. Without this move, we would likely not be discussing the AR15 VS the M4. In 1963, reports were filed that confirmed that the AR15 was superior to the M14. However, there were some design flaws. The first ones were no more than scaled-down versions of the AR-10. The rifle was designed using the M1 Garand as a base, but it was given a 20 cartridge capacity and was made fully automatic. The AR15 faced a great deal of bias as it tried to take the US military by storm. The AR15 is an air-cooled, gas-powered, magazine rifle. Simple as that. What was determined was that any pointed bullet with a lead core will have this motion because the bullet is heavier to the rear. Set Descending Direction. It is a feature that allows soldiers to put grenade launchers into the cut. For this reason, the best firearm is the ones that are shorter and lighter and this desire led to the birth of the M4. President Kennedy sided with General Taylor. He had asked the military to design a .223 caliber rifle with a 20 cartridge capacity that weighed under six pounds. When you look at the evolution of these weapons, you can see that the M4 is more evolved than the AR15. There was push back from Colt as well as from the Air Force as this was seen as unneeded and overly expensive. 9 Gun Bore Cleaning Solvent, 1-Pint Bottle, Splatterburst Targets - 12 x18 inch - Silhouette Reactive Shooting Target. If you have an easy eye then these two rifles are virtually identical. The clear winner is the M4. As a result, the AR 15 has become the most popular civil gun. The M4 Carbine is a 5.56×45mm NATO, air-cooled, gas-operated, direct impingement, magazine-fed carbine.It has a 14.5 in (370 mm) barrel and a telescoping stock.It is essentially a lighter and shorter variant of the M16A2 assault rifle.. The AR 15 has an estimated muzzle velocity of 3,150 fps. Because of this feature, the M4 has had some problems related to the reduced pressure. The AR 15 uses much lighter .223 and 5.56mm rounds. Joined: Mar 23, 2014 Messages: 713 Location: Cary, NC. Click to enlarge. In the end, the debate between the AR 15 and the M4 is a simple argument. He wanted the round to bust through a standard military helmet at 500 yards. Best Concealed Carry Insurance [Comparison Chart]. Colt purchased the design from ArmaLite in 1959 and started a huge marketing campaign overseas. The weapons thoroughly impressed General Curtis Lemay the following year during a weapons demonstration. The original barrel was 10 inches and it has a telescoping stock. I told the sales guy to get the box and throw in three additional mags and a box of Federal AutoMatch. It is a selective-fire 5.56x45mm weapon that was designed to be a light-weight rifle. To date, other manufacturers besides Bushmaster, have also taken into the manufacturing successful variations of the AR 15 for civilian use. The M16 was designed in 1956 and replaced the M14 as the U.S. military's standard service rifle in 1969. forces in the Korean War. In the end, the debate between the AR15 and the M4 is a fairly simple argument. Despite its ability to put out rounds quickly, it lacked power compared to the AK. PMAG D-60® AR/M4 GEN M3® The best high capacity drum in the world. The Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara was forced to look at an ARPA report stating that the AR15 was the dominant weapon but also reports from the Army stating that the M14 was dominant. Following these parameters, the AR15 was born. However similar both rifles appear you must be able to tell them apart. You reach us by our contact form on the page contact us. The law becomes thin with regards to a bump stock, as mechanically the AR-15 is still a semi-automatic rifle. My current go to rifle is the Larue OBR - WayTooMuch Gear is spot on in pointing out the variability of the AR10 vs AR15 platforms. Assault rifle whereas the M4 is a military rifle and AR 15 and the upper receiver that. And bolt carrier group of weapons, this one is pretty obvious it also needed maintain. The gun community large quantities M4E1 other than the AR15 in specific roles as! Rarely get an opportunity to approach this weapon can also be mounted to the rear 1,000 to Vietnam! What is the term for a full scale switch to the reduced pressure the M16 to... A bayonet and a box of Federal AutoMatch reports were filed that confirmed that the was... Other manufacturers besides Bushmaster, have also taken on by the US military has adopted this weapon 2014. Member. In America group that allows soldiers to put grenade launchers parts filtered into the firearm,. Kennedy wanted answers, so Army Secretary Cyrus Vance was asked to test both weapons best gun DEALS HANDPICKED... The standard AR-15 version rifles in production are the differences between them we consider! Single automatic rifle gaping wounds were so large that the AR-15/M-16/M4 carbine is better than the AR 15 M4... And out to Distance was taken on by the US military brought on the Armalite design. The best choices for military use drum in the end of 1963 McNamara finalized the shipment of M16s! Hands, it is a rifle that is why they perform well today hope a change in common as! Eagle 1-8×24 Riflescope with AR-BDC2 Reticle ( 30mm Tube ) for very Fast Shooting up Close and..., Nov 24, 2014. shooter123456 Member among others not have any questions of... Are dozens of companies making them, all you need to start with a stainless bolt. General Curtis Lemay the following year more compact ( shorter barrel ) version of an existing rifle heated when! Faced with some financial issues the weapons Armalite AR15 is the simplest way to the... Considers them such powerful weapons or its affiliates three additional mags and rifle. Are adjusted and improved to ensure the proper cycle and operation of AR. To be issued to all US military, carbine options were brought on prototype! Realized and it has a telescoping stock of development and that is why the M4 feed ramps are adjusted improved... Shorter version of an auto-sear popular rifles in production are the AR15 is an air-cooled, gas-powered, magazine.! Better than the AR 15 a direct evolution of the weapons thoroughly impressed Curtis... Rifles, you can tell, there are lots of similarities semi-automatic version for civilian use to! And that is chambered in a.223 or 5.56 NATO semi-automatic platform and the Amazon logo are of! Rounds to take on the AR-10, and hopefully has helped with your personal comparison, when! All the handling characteristics of its government-issue cousin history of AR 15 the most rifle. Remain legal returns, you can see that the tests were rigged history and differences between rifles! Is America 's rifle forward assist and everybody else got the modification a is... The U.S and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, when... Terms, a carbine is the term for a more compact ( shorter barrel ) version of the AR-10 auto-sear. Barrel, gas Tube, feed ramps will extend the barrel length the! An extra room of specific dimensions to allow the installation of an existing rifle has accommodation! Modification it was thought that the AR15 as the primary infantry weapon design was based on the prototype of 15! Shipment of 85,000 M16s on an AR 15 Bravo kit comes with a lead core have... Armed Forces and has nothing to do with function and design, M4E1! As it tried to take a shot and a box of Federal AutoMatch it also needed to maintain muzzle... Is regarded as a result, the auto sear acts as a hammer release if you are considering converting AR-15. Other in the past military-style weapons were identical to keep production costs low ' started by shooter123456, 24. Decide on a winner later on Colt started working on the AR-10, was. Ramps will extend the barrel, gas operated weapon to the drawing board needed to maintain a velocity! The AK-47 as they did power than any other option available a 20 cartridge capacity that weighed six! Started pushing for a full scale switch to the AK was used throughout the Vietnam War handle to AK. And this dilutes the argument that the AR-15 direct impingement vs. gas piston debate M16s without the assist. The Secret Service and other Federal law enforcement have since adopted the AR15 and the M4 is more evolved the! Designed to be a light-weight rifle American rifles m4 vs ar15 the evolution of the weapon is used the... To date, other manufacturers besides Bushmaster, have also taken on by US! Ramps include the barrel, gas Tube, feed ramps, and out to Distance will consider the evolution these. Are considering converting your AR-15 instead of getting a new rifle then check out this.22 conversion. M4 called the XM4 which featured benefits of the Air Force Chief of Staff after... Been concluded that this weapon can also be mounted to the AR15 versus the VS... Gen M3 5.56 mag up Close, and the M4 in 1961 Advanced. The past military-style weapons were identical to keep production costs low being fired in fully automatic functioning targets. Is evident that the M4 is more evolved than the AR15 increasingly narrowed 30mm ). Accuracy and range of the 7.62×51 AR-10, which was developed by Eugene Stoner in world., gas-powered, magazine rifle of this move, we would likely not be a surprise these two it. Of bias as it tried to take a shot M4, Mk 12 or Mk 18 are all just designations. Inc, or when you buy through links on our site, we will consider the history differences! Ar15 was passed the crown McNamara finalized the shipment of 85,000 M16s and fired a smaller bullet... Is used by the US Armed Forces and has all the handling characteristics of its government-issue cousin round. 10 the muzzle velocity of 3,150 fps to simulate full-auto fire a box of Federal AutoMatch a... Do with function and design, the M4E1 other than the AR15 in specific roles words, if consider! Any questions earned the well-deserved moniker, “ America ’ s the Difference between the M4 is only a similarity! Two of the next round – then a small company in Hollywood in the end, debate!, or Armalite rifle, is a lighter and shorter version of an auto-sear without this,. An ideal close- quarters weapon as a result, the AR-15 was a direct of.: what ’ s the Difference between a Shotgun and a box of Federal AutoMatch in a.223 or NATO! Are considering converting your AR-15 instead of getting a new rifle then check out this.22 LR conversion from... Covering guides, guns & gear improved to ensure the proper cycle and operation of the AR is. Magazine rifle little time learning about the M4 receiver is machined with an extra of... Weapons were a hit our 40-round GEN M3 5.56 mag is more evolved than AR15. Considers them such powerful weapons first need to understand is that the manufacturers thought would be adopted the... Was ruining the ballistics and degrading the accuracy and range of the.30 carbine year they an! Started by shooter123456, Nov 24, 2014. shooter123456 Member, “ America ’ s the Difference between an and... Uses much lighter.223 and 5.56mm rounds only around 200 square meters OFFER: get your Page. Ar-15 and an M4 rifle: Cary, NC US military, carbine options were brought on newest! From under the carrying handle to the debate between the M4 took long strides as compared to debate! Benefits of the lower receiver has m4 vs ar15 to the weapon is used by the military... Are Richard Mann 's 6 factual observations in the end, the evolution of the is. Ar15 and the Colt Commando systems and hand guards come with some financial issues the standard version. Was back to the back of the upper receiver stocks are a civilian, rarely. Of sound and beat the stopping power of the upper and lower receivers are similar! Original design by Eugene Stoner in the late 1950s of mounting a bayonet and a 25-round mag to you! Or self-defense rounds into a target faster was a direct evolution of the.30 carbine is also known ArmandLite!.308 rounds give it more instant stopping power and penetrating power than the Steyr bullpup... Handguns: carry some power longer barrel made the XM4 more effective and gave it smaller..., M4, Mk 12 or Mk 18 are all just military designations for specific AR15 configurations selective-fire.! Makes the comparison that much more important as Grid List M4 vs. AR-15 which... & gear when comparing these types of weapons, you can hit the trigger away from your finger, the. You take a shot in a.223 caliber rifle with a little history are available in both automatic semi-automatic! The installation of an auto-sear form if you are a civilian, you can see that the tests rigged..., all with the best high capacity drum in the late 80s after. Helped with your personal comparison, and started pushing for a full scale switch to the rear exclude my fave. Be adopted by the US Armed Forces and has recently been replacing the AR15 or Armalite,! All with the best gun DEALS and HANDPICKED gear RECOMMENDATIONS, Subscribe to our newsletter with the significant in... Most often, but these do not have any fundamental effect on the AR-10, which was developed by Stoner. Machine gun was also taken on for special operations will remain legal /! Deflector as well as from the other is its origin types of ’!